Five Arguments for and Against the iPad
- March 15th, 2010 - 1.30 pm UTC
- WoA Feature Articles, iPad
- Alex Brooks

Apple iPad
It doesn’t often take much persuading for me to purchase a new Apple product, especially one with such interest and potential as the iPad. But when pre-orders opened late last week I didn’t whip out the plastic and checkout my basket. Issues of being in the UK aside there appear to be reasons why I don’t think the iPad will suit my needs.
As far as I see it the times I would need the iPad are when I’m away from my desk, whether that be travelling, round a friends or simply lying in bed too lazy to hobble over to my desk. In all of those situations I use my MacBook Pro and it offers me a no limits solution, not so with the iPad.
So let me get into it, let’s start with why I feel an iPad will complete my workflow and make my life easier (and cooler).
For
Portability
The iPad weighs just over half a kilogram (1.5 pounds for the imperial lovers) compare that to my couple of year old MacBook Pro and you have a very compelling reason why the iPad can be thrown into a bag without much thought. In fact the iPad weighs a little under five times less than my MacBook Pro, perfect.
Media
Like it or not the iPad spawned from the iPhone which inevitable spawned from the success of the iPod and the iPod is all about media. In terms of the iPad the idea of media has expanded somewhat, we’re no longer just talking photos, movies, TV, music and podcasts add into the mix newspapers, magazines and books.

Apple iPad running New York Times app
I read lots of newspapers, I read the ones I can’t buy in paper online and the ones I can buy in paper form, pile up by my desk until I have a four foot tall tower of untidy paper.
I’m hoping that the delivery of media such as newspapers and magazines and to the same extent books becomes as easy as it is now with movies and TV shows. A month long subscription to the New York Times or Guardian via the iTunes Store will hopefully see the papers turn up on my iPad with no effort on my part. Details of how this will work are yet to be revealed but I can see it working that way if pre-ordered music and subscriptions to TV shows is anything to go by.
Ease of Use
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying that using Mac OS X on my MacBook Pro is a hardship but creating documents, editing photos and sorting email will be easier when using all of my fingers not just a pointer on the end of a mouse. I already experience this with the iPhone and it has its disadvantages, some websites are difficult to navigate and typing long emails is daunting but hopefully the iPads large display will conquer these issues.
Anything to save me time and effort is a winner in my book.
Price
It doesn’t matter how much money you have, it’s natural to seek out the best priced solution for what you need. My MacBook Pro is feeling long in the tooth, I can’t survive solely with a desktop machine so a solution is required; the iPad is certainly a cheaper solution than a new MacBook Pro. Sure it lacks expandability, storage and some functions but do I really need all this when away from my desk (that question is exactly why I’m writing this).
Apple Factor
Stick with me here, I’m not stretching for reasons in favour of the iPad. In my eyes and many eyes I imagine this is a genuine reason, the cool factor of owning an iPhone in the first few months of release was eye opening. The iPad has as much avid interested outside of the usual geek circles, nothing like leading a trend.

iPad showing Star Trek movie
Against
Display
Apple rarely makes questionable choices with hardware, the company led the pack with LED backlit displays and always pushes out the old for new but the iPad’s display is interesting to say the least. The iPad if you didn’t know packs a 9.7-inch display with a resolution of 1024 x 768. That’s a display with a ratio of 4:3, far from the norm of 16:9 displays. I can see Apple’s thought process – good for the web, books, newspapers; bad for movies.
I have to say that my use of the iPad for movies and TV would be high, this display ratio would certainly be a pain. The only solutions are cropping or large black bars top and bottom.
Multitasking
Now we get to the real crux of the negatives, How am I meant to operate a workflow like I do now if I can only run one application at a time? As I write this post I’m running several other applications, I have my email, Tweetie, iTunes, NetNewsWire and Adium. On the iPad I would be writing this and running this application alone, sure I can play some music and sure my email is still working but I have to quit what I’m doing to read my email, rather than just pausing what I’m doing.
This leads me nicely onto my next negative…
On-Device Storage
Browse the iPad website and you’ll find no mention of on-device storage, the iWork productivity apps are featured prominently but no mention of where documents created are saved. “On the cloud” I hear you say, well this is all well and good but what if I’m not connected to the cloud?
Let’s say I’ve created 15 slides in Keynote and I want to source an image from the web, I quit Keynote open Safari find my image. Where do I save my image, does the iPad have a camera roll, it doesn’t have a camera!? Where did I save my Keynote presentation?
I’ll admit that this issue will become clear, but the issue at hand is the issue of whether I should pre-order a device that I’m not entirely sure how it’ll work.

Apple iPad running multi-touch versions of Keynote, Pages and Numbers
Apps
There are 150,000 apps in the App Store according to Apple, that’s a staggering number but they’re all built for the iPhone. iPad apps will flow thick and fast I’m sure of it but I’m left wondering whether holes in my productivity will go unfulfilled.
Photoshop is available in the App Store, but will a more comprehensive version be available for the iPad, Reeder is great for the iPhone but will a version be made to take advantage of the iPads significant screen real estate? These questions go on and I realise it’s early days but once again this is the question of pre-ordering or not.
The Final Issue
Truth is I don’t have a fifth negative; I’m not bothered by the lack of Flash, limited expandability, closed ecosystem or even the fact that the Wi-Fi + 3G version uses a micro SIM. None of that bothers me.
Why don’t you tell me what is holding you back from buying an iPad?










