In Brief: Alabama Woman Sues Over Alleged iPhone 3G Defects
- August 21st, 2008 - 4.30 pm UTC
- Apple Legal News
- dizzle
On August 19, 2008, in the Northern District of Alabama (Case No. 2:08-cv-01498-WMA, Judge William M. Acker, Jr. presiding) Jessica Alena Smith filed a Class Action Complaint against Apple, Inc. allegeding that the iPhone 3G did not live up to the ubiquitous advertised promise of “twice the speed, half the price.” The Complaint comprises three counts: Breach of Express Warranty, Breach of the Implied Warranty of Merchantability, and Unjust Enrichment. Although the Complaint was filed as a class action, the case is not actually a class action suit until it has been certified as such by the Court. Ms. Smith has alleged that there is an “aggregate amount in controversy exceeding $5,000,000, exclusive of interest and costs.”
Her prayers for relief include certification of class, any and all damages to which the Plaintiff and Class members might be entitled, interest on any damages awarded, injunctive and/or declaratory relief including “an order that requires Defendant to repair and/or replace its Defective iPhone 3G,” and attorneys’ fees and costs. Don’t ask me why the word “defective” is capitalized. Attorneys tend to live in their own capitalization world. Ms. Smith requested and was granted permission to serve Apple by certified mail. Service has not yet been effectuated. Apple will have twenty days after service of the summons to file a responsive pleading.
Comments
Edfrommars 21st August 2008, 16.54 pm
What a ridiculous case. My guess is that there will be a settlement out of court.
Dizzle 21st August 2008, 17.41 pm
That is my guess too. Apple is already coming up with a fix for the few persons with problems (I have never personally met any of them), her attorneys will get most of any settlement. I am going to monitor the case and post updates here at WOA.
Munky 22nd August 2008, 04.28 am
I would like to high five that woman. I have had the iphone 3g for a good month now. If you just google Iphone 3g and click on news results, you will see the tens of thousands of articles on the problem. I am also experiencing the problem.
I hope she wins, And I would like to get involved in this case!!!
MaddogUK 22nd August 2008, 10.10 am
By settling out of court means Apple are wrong and are paying to make the truth go away. These phones (like many others) are hyped well beyond there real limits.
Engineers are blaming problems on the hardware so yet another fix may not change anything. Apple live & sell by the hype the create so must pay for it in litigious countries when the hype does not match the product.